Review Report:  Design Document

Reading Assessment

Ayotunde Phillips

Date:  03/26/2002


Review

Date Made Date Addressed Artifact Section Issue/Praise Suggestion
03/21/2002   System Architecture System architecture seems to indicate that all the web pages are on the same level but some pages are sub pages of other pages. 

 

I would suggest that the main page should be on the first level, the pages that the main page links to be on the second level and their sub pages on the subsequent levels.
03/21/2002   Similar and Supporting Work The similar and supporting work section is incomplete. An internet search might be used to find similar software currently available.
03/25/2002   Detailed Design
  • The design team might consider renumbering the detailed design – section 5. Every section after section 5.1 seems to be going into detail about the components of section 5.1. 
  • Sections 5.4 and 5.5 have the same diagram. Also there is no “questions page” in the main page subsystem. 

     

     

 

  • The design team might consider using lower number such as 5.1.1, 5.1.2 and so on for the sections that come after the 5.1.
  • I would also suggest that section 5.7 should have a diagram to illustrate the path to the calculations page like subsequent questions for uniformity.
  • I would suggest that a key to the diagrams in section 5 should be listed at the beginning of section.

Tallies

Total Number of Issue Entries Total Number of  Issues Addressed Total Number of Invalidated Issues Total Number of Praise Entries
 4  0  0  0